".... It occurred to me listening to Crowley and Obama's firm but somewhat muted public reactions to Iran's decision to enrich to a higher grade, that one thing they want to avoid is the kind of rhetorical escalation that might have Iran reduce cooperation with the IAEA. The IAEA currently has observers at the Natanz pilot facility where Iran is conducting the 20% uranium enrichment.
Meantime, Paris-based Intelligence Online today reports that Swiss Foreign Secretary Mickael Ambuhl has initiated a set of meetings between the U.S. and Iran in Geneva:
Officially, the Iranian Vice President Esfandiar Rahim Mashaie was in Geneva February 1 to attract investors to the Kish Island Persian Gulf Sea Project. But according to our information, Meshaie also took part in secret meetings with American officials, just days before Iran announced its intention to enrich uranium by 20% instead of the current 3.5%. Meshaei's presence in Geneva coincided with the presence at the United Nations' headquarters in the city of the large delegation of American nuclear specialists who had come to finalize the new Start treaty with the Russians.
For several months, Switzerland has hosted a series of meetings between the U.S. and Iran. Mickael Ambuhl, the Foreign Secretary, initiated these contacts last year under the authority of the Foreign Minister, Micheline Calmy Rey. Ambuhl recently moved to the Finance Ministry, but the meetings are still going on. The Swiss Embassy serves as the protecting power for U.S. interests in Iran, where Washington does not have an embassy."
"'America is something that can be easily moved. Moved to the right direction.They won’t get in our way'" Benjamin Netanyahu
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
Obama: Avoid rhetorical escalation that leads to Iran reducing cooperation with the IAEA ... & meetings between the US & Iran in Geneva
Syria regains strength in Lebanon, without troop presence .... Saudi, Western rapprochement with Syria sealed new reality
"Slowly but surely, Syria has regained influence in Lebanon, but wields it more diplomatically than in the era before the slaying of Lebanese statesman Rafik al-Hariri ..... with a green light from Hariri's regional ally Saudi Arabia, it has recovered its standing abroad, shrugging off Western efforts to isolate it and developing strong new ties with Turkey, a former enemy."There was not even the pretence of diplomacy and dignity," recalled Karim Makdisi, "It's not so much that Lebanon is now a sovereign country," he said, but a more normal relationship had been restored.....The younger Hariri became prime minister after his Western- and Saudi-backed coalition narrowly won a June election against Hezbollah and other Syrian allies. But he heads a national unity government in which the minority enjoys significant power.Lebanese politicians who had hoped the United States, France and Saudi Arabia would block any Syrian interference after the last Syrian troops left in April 2005 have trimmed their sails.Druze leader Walid Jumblatt, once one of Syria's fieriest critics, left the Hariri-led coalition last year to take a more centrist stance -- and is expected to visit Damascus soon.For Marwan Hamadeh, a Jumblatt aide who survived an attempt on his life in October 2004, the new relationship with Syria stops short of genuine reconciliation and cannot obstruct an international tribunal formed to prosecute Hariri's killers."I wouldn't say the Syrians are back," he told Reuters. "In political and intelligence terms they never left.....Most Lebanese politicians now clear their lines with Syria.President Michel Suleiman, a former army commander, holds a weekly call with Assad. Hariri has spoken by telephone to the Syrian leader several times since his trip to Damascus."Once the Syrians and Saudis got together, local politicians would always have to dance to their music," said Makdisi.Anti-Syrian politicians had to compromise because they had realised that Lebanon was "not the centre of the universe" and Western leaders would not come to their rescue, he added.Syria sees its influence in Lebanon as a trump card in any negotiations with the West and Israel, Hamadeh said. The West still wanted to keep Lebanon from coming under Syria's thumb again. "But everything in this world is now relative, especially independence and sovereignty," he shrugged....But progress could be slow on measures that Hariri sees as vital to reinforce a normal state-to-state relationship.....Hariri no longer publicly accuses Syria of orchestrating the huge seafront bomb blast that killed his father and 22 others, saying he will await the outcome of the U.N.-backed tribunal.Investigators initially implicated Syrian and Lebanese security officials, but the tribunal has yet to indict any suspects and critics say it appears to have lost momentum.Lebanese commentator Michael Young said the United States and France, both hostile to Syria at the time, had spearheaded efforts to set up the tribunal, but now had other priorities."Today there is no critical mass to see the tribunal accuse Syria or anybody else. For many in the international community, the tribunal is more a headache than anything else," he argued.Makdisi, the academic, said the tribunal had a life of its own, but might never uncover the truth behind Hariri's killing.
Sex-video of Mahmoud Abbas' office manager, rubbing his body against his secretary ...& other glorious tidbits"
"... The report also aired claims made by former General Intelligence chief Fahmi Shabana that officials close to Abbas and his predecessor Yasser Arafat were entangled in corruption scandals amounting to millions of shekels stolen from public coffers...... Shabana also revealed an embarrassing video from 2008 depicting the head of Abbas' office, Rafik al-Husseini, rubbing his body against his secretary and apparently trying to convince a woman seeking employment in the office to have sexual relations with him.....The PA claimed further that Shabana was arrested for three months for corruption scandals that he himself was involved in and alleged that he recently tried to blackmail senior PA officials in order to receive the post of deputy governor of Jerusalem...."
"Informal Crippling Proposals ..."
France and the United States have both prepared informal papers outlining the kinds of punitive measures against Iran the 15-nation Security Council could approve....Among the possible targets are Iran's central bank, which Western diplomats say has been a key player in financing Tehran's nuclear and missile programs and in skirting previously approved U.N. sanctions....One diplomat said that they were considering the idea of blacklisting Iran's five biggest banks.
One idea under consideration is adding members of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and companies controlled by it to a list of individuals and firms facing travel bans and asset freezes....
They could blacklist Iranian shipping companies. Two firms -- Iran Air Cargo and Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines -- were mentioned in the March 2008 sanctions resolution.....
The idea of expanding the existing U.N. ban on arms exports from Iran to include a ban on arms imports is being discussed....
The French sanctions paper includes a general call for targeting Iran's energy sector. Although the United States, like Britain, supports the idea of targeting Iran's oil and gas industries, the U.S. paper does not call for it. The reason for leaving it out, diplomats say, is that Washington is concerned that including it now could unnecessarily delay the process of negotiating a sanctions package that is acceptable to Russia and China..."
"...The Obama administration seems leery of banking its Iran policy on a protest movement that could sputter out or be crushed ..."
"At first blush, it seems like a godsend for U.S. foreign policy: a tenacious Iranian opposition, democratic in name at least, is challenging a regime that has caused the United States no end of headaches over the last 30 years......Senior U.S. officials expressed empathy for the protestors in interviews with McClatchy. But given the sorry history of American intervention in Iran, anything the U.S. government did to try to help would do more harm than good, they said. In addition, the Obama administration seems leery of banking its Iran policy on a protest movement that could sputter out or be crushed."We're in for a stalemate . . . an extended one," predicted a senior State Department official, who requested anonymity because of the issue's sensitivity. The opposition will persist "but won't be capable of bringing down the government."The regime, led by Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamanei, has so far been unwilling to order a full-scale, Tiananmen Square-like massacre of the protesters. "The government is concerned about crossing a limit where they risk losing the loyalty of their own security forces," the official said....In parallel to the looming confrontation, Iran and western countries are in an increasingly tense standoff over Tehran's nuclear program. .....All efforts to foment political change in Iran from the outside "have been a complete, utter failure," said Trita Parsi, president of the National Iranian American Council. Still, he said, "the silence on the human rights front is coming across as extremely strange."The risk, Parsi said, is that both the Iranian regime and the protesters will conclude that Obama is so eager for a nuclear deal, he's willing to play down human rights.Fatemeh Haghighatjoo, a reformist member of Iran's parliament from 2000 to 2004, said Obama distrusts Mousavi and other "green movement" leaders because they, too, support Iran's nuclear development. "I want to say this is wrong," Haghighatjoo said, adding that nuclear technology in the hands of Iranian democrats is much different than the same technology controlled by Iran's theocratic regime. She spoke at an event at the U.S. Institute of Peace.Inside Washington's Beltway, the fate of Iran's regime has prompted a bitter verbal battle.Those pushing for more action include prominent "neoconservatives" who led the push for the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003.But one of them, Robert Kagan, of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said he's not calling for a U.S. invasion of Iran, and that the situation there should be compared not to Iraq, but to the former Soviet Union, the Philippines or South Africa before their revolutions...."
"...The whole incident consists of more huffing & puffing than real brinksmanship ..."
"... Iran analysts are scrambling to figure out how the mysterious "punch" might land. For now, most are scratching their heads. More likely than not, they say, the whole incident consists of more huffing and puffing than real brinksmanship. “The Iranians are trouble to be sure, but they’re also known to exaggerate their capabilities, especially when it comes to their military and nuclear programs," said one U.S. counterterrorism official. "They have multiple incentives to hype the facts—to try to deter a potential attack from abroad, to strike a better bargain in international negotiations, or to stoke nationalism at home."That squares with what Iran watchers know about the regime's capabilities at this point. The reality is that Iran isn't yet in a position to carry out a nuclear test. Attacks on foreign soil seem similarly improbable. Although Iranian leaders are famous for their blustery threats, nobody can quite believe Khamenei would risk pursuing an actual attack on Israel or a terrorist act in the West, which would both provoke more confrontation than they're worth. In line with the drone testing, it is possible that the "punch" could be some sort of longer-range missile test. Still, while cause for concern, that would hardly constitute a threat worth hyperventilating over. Even less troubling (at least in the geopolitical sense) is our colleague Maziar Bahari's assessment. "He just means that everyone will come to the street and will show how popular Iranian government is," he wrote in an e-mail.What would be more cause for concern—and probably more to Tehran's liking—is if the provocation were to yield a Western strike, a move that could undermine the opposition movement by uniting dissidents and the regime in patriotic anger over foreign intervention. That leaves a prickly path to tread for Western officials. Monday brought news that the Russians were finally on board with a program of sanctions, but China is standing strong as the lone holdout on the U.N. Security Council. As Melinda Liu points out, prospects for Chinese acquiescence are not good. If they're unable to reign in Iran's top trading partner, Western leaders may have to settle on an alternative response. The danger would be choosing one that plays right into Khamenei's hand."
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
"... Si le régime iranien veut la bombe, il sera difficile à stopper ..."
"L’Iran a-t-il franchi un point de non-retour ? La dĂ©cision de pousser le taux d’enrichissement de l’uranium au-delĂ de 20 % est inquiĂ©tante car, Ă partir de ce taux, il est relativement facile de pousser l’enrichissement jusqu’Ă 90 %, qui est le niveau requis pour concevoir une ogive nuclĂ©aire. En ce sens, l’Iran a bel et bien franchi une ligne rouge. L’offre d’Ă©change de combustible nĂ©gociĂ©e en octobre (transfert Ă l’Ă©tranger de tout le stock d’uranium iranien pour retraitement, contre acquisition d’uranium enrichi Ă 20 %) tient-elle encore ?
En substance, l’Iran dĂ©clare ĂŞtre en mesure de pouvoir tout Ă la fois produire cet uranium hautement enrichi, l’acheter Ă l’Ă©tranger et procĂ©der Ă un tel Ă©change. Or, cela vide de son sens le principe mĂŞme d’un tel troc. Quel intĂ©rĂŞt y a-t-il Ă prendre le risque de se sĂ©parer de tout son stock d’uranium faiblement enrichi si l’on peut acheter, voire produire soimĂŞme le combustible dont on a besoin ? L’Iran a-t-il l’intention de se doter de l’arme nuclĂ©aire ? Les dirigeants iraniens ont Ă©voquĂ© un possible enrichissement de l’uranium au laser. Le hic, c’est que ce genre de technologie est tout bonnement parfait si l’on veut fabriquer une arme nuclĂ©aire. C’est en revanche beaucoup moins viable dans le cadre d’un programme civil. Si le rĂ©gime iranien veut la bombe, il sera difficile Ă stopper car il dispose Ă prĂ©sent du savoir-faire pour cela.
"Iran is in Obama's sights ... but not before 2011..."
"........ Chilton, who as a teenager was a surfer in Southern California, deserves to be called Kevin Spacey - he is a veteran of both NASA and the Air Force space command, wearing the wings of an astronaut who peered down at Earth during three space voyages. He well understands the anxiety in Israel. His hosts brought him, as usual, to Yad Vashem. But in his conversation with Israel Air Force commander Ido Nehushtan and Deputy Chief of Staff Benny Gantz, Chilton didn't offer even a hint of readiness to engage in any operational coordination against their mutual rival. On the contrary: He wondered if it might somehow be possible to persuade Iran to abandon its effort to develop nuclear arms, in order to stave off an aggressive confrontation. Chilton may have been joking when he said that each senior command echelon in the United States has an even more senior command echelon above it - with the only exception being Mrs. Barack Obama - but when it comes to vital matters of foreign affairs and defense, one should never misinterpret: The general expressed Obama's desire to delay the inevitable.
Iran is definitely in Obama's sights. He has ceased courting it, and is girding for the confrontation. But not yet. Evidently, it will not be this year. Thus, if Netanyahu wants to attack Iran, he's going to have to take into account four major indices: substantive need, operational capability, internal support and external consent. Only the confluence of extremely high scores in all four of these areas would allow him to spearhead the decision to launch an operation.
As far as substantive need goes, as of last month, Iran did not yet have nuclear arms. Public pronouncements by senior U.S. intelligence and Pentagon officials more or less corroborate the assessments in Israel.....
Another prerequisite for an Israeli attack, which has prevailed for years, is the state of hostility between Israel and Iran on the terror front, but it is not sufficient by itself to justify a strike. Iran has attacked Israel relentlessly through its proxies in Hezbollah, Hamas and other organizations, via financing, training and direct supervision by the Revolutionary Guard and the foreign terrorist attack division of Iranian intelligence. Israel does not make do with indulgent acceptance of the Iranian attacks. If the Mossad indeed assassinated Mahmoud al-Mabhouh of Hamas in Dubai, the motive most probably had less to do with the past than with the present - namely, with his recent role as a Hamas liaison with Iran, rather than as revenge for the murder of soldiers Ilan Saadon and Avi Sasportas two decades ago.
As for capability: Prior to making a decision on the question of launching an operation against Iran, Netanyahu would need an unequivocal statement from the defense establishment that Israel possesses the military ability to hit targets and accomplish the objectives that will be set, at least in relative terms (i.e., wreaking damage that could be reversed in a few years, as opposed to total destruction from which there could be no recovery). ....
At any given moment, one can reasonably conclude that there is no unity of opinion among the officers who would be consulted, either when it comes to assessments and or recommendations. Among Gen. Nehushtan's predecessors, Eliezer Shkedi was more belligerent on the Iranian question than Dan Halutz. Seasoned defense officials are aware that special operations, such as the assassination of Mabhouh (if it was indeed carried out by Israel), do not necessarily reflect an army's or nation's capability in war. The attacker always has a momentary and fleeting advantage that does not reflect his capacity to defend and absorb. The Israel that carried out assassinations of Black September operatives in Europe in 1973, for example, was not adequately prepared for the Yom Kippur War.
As for the subject of domestic support, Netanyahu is bleeding, said one of his political rivals this week, no matter what the polls may say. The capitulation of a majority of the cabinet and of the Knesset is preventing an all-out crash, but is not sufficient for him to be able to soar. There is no reverence for the premier. Without an ample measure of political prowess, security leadership and moral authority, you do not take a country into an initiated war, a war of choice.
In terms of external consent, Gens. Chilton and Petraeus and chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Adm. Mike Mullen, who met Ashkenazi in Brussels last week, have an influence on Obama, but primarily are attentive to his policy, which is mainly concerned this year with stabilizing the economy, disconnecting from Iraq, fighting more effectively in Afghanistan, and easing tension with China and Russia - partly for the purpose of tightening the ring around Iran. The American military sees Iran and North Korea as "regional aggressors" that threaten to spur a nuclear race and to undermine stability at two edges of Asia. The conflict with one of the two, with preference for Iran, is growing closer, but is still possible to prevent.
The spokesman of the Obama administration's National Security Council, Mike Hammer, last month described the transition from dialogue with Tehran to sanctions against it as the "pressure track." Last year was the year of public relations; 2010 is the year of pressure. The crushing blow that comes after the pressure will not be dealt before next year.
Petraeus, in speaking about Iraq and Afghanistan, recently referred to the difference between "Washington time" and "Baghdad, or Kabul, time": Iranian nuclearization is conducted according to Tehran time, but Obama takes a look at the Washington clock and sees in it the congressional elections in November.
During the waiting period, until 2011 arrives, Israel can intensify its intelligence capability, spruce up its military power, and it would also be wise to place at its head a political leadership that can be relied upon."
'Regime Change' in Iran? No thanks ...
" .... History shows that intervention is easier said than done. Past U.S. attempts to sway Iranian internal affairs -- such as the CIA-fomented 1953 coup d'état against a democratically elected prime minister, Mohammad Mossadegh -- have proven costly for U.S. interests. Most notably, Washington's support for the shah fueled the 1979 Islamic Revolution, inspiring anti-Western movements in Pakistan, Egypt, and beyond.To make matters worse, due to its absence from the scene during the last 30 years, the United States is not sufficiently equipped to understand and shape what appears to be a titanic struggle between Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and his opponents.
But between the extremes of doing nothing and doing everything, there is a middle ground: providing the Iranian pro-democracy movement with breathing space, rather than engaging in risky and imprecise exercises that would directly involve America as an actor on the Iranian scene. The United States can achieve this through a few simple steps.
Monday, February 8, 2010
"... the can't-live-with-'em-can't-live-without-'em U.S.-Syrian relationship is about to enter a new phase..."
Unlike many U.S. embassies in the Arab world that have been forced by security concerns to move from the center of capital cities to fortress-like suburban compounds, the Damascus embassy still occupies prime real estate — just a stone's throw from the residence of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. Syria's much feared state-security apparatus keeps close tabs on everyone entering and leaving the embassy, but it also helps keeps the embassy relatively safe from the occasional jihadist sneak attack............. news that the embassy is set, for the first time in five years, to have a resident ambassador is a sign that the can't-live-with-'em-can't-live-without-'em U.S.-Syrian relationship is about to enter a new phase. The State Department has presented the credentials of Robert Ford, former U.S. deputy ambassador to Iraq, to the Syrian government for approval as ambassador in Damascus, according to the Syrian government. ......Although the U.S. still accuses Syria of supporting militant groups in the region, the appointment of a new ambassador is recognition of a new spirit of partial cooperation from Damascus. Since the waning days of the Bush years, Syria has helped tighten its border with Iraq to prevent jihadists from crossing; it has for the first time recognized Lebanon's sovereignty by opening an embassy in Beirut; and has regularly called for direct peace talks with Israel. The reappointment of an ambassador would also be of a piece with the Obama Administration's strategic policy to engage its adversaries, and with wider U.S. geopolitical interests in the Middle East. Though the Bush Administration first toyed with toppling the Assad regime and then settled for simply ignoring it, Obama has tried to coax Syria away from the so-called rejectionist crescent — the arc of countries and militant groups from Tehran to Gaza that stand in opposition to U.S. and Israeli power.For Syria, the return of an American ambassador is a much desired signal that the U.S. needs Syria — to help stabilize Iraq, to keep the peace in Lebanon and to solve the Arab-Israeli conflict. Syrians like to think of their country as the crossroads of the Middle East, and grew worried when Damascus simply fell off the itinerary of most major world players. Even more worrying is the country's dismal neo-Soviet-style economy, which needs reform and foreign investment if it is to create enough jobs for the country's young, growing and restless population.But if Mr. Ford does indeed take the road to Damascus, he will want more than just Arab hospitality when he gets there. He'll expect Syria to distance itself from its old friends in Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and Hizballah, and will hope to coax Assad away from his alliance with Iran. But the Syrians aren't in such a hurry. While Damascus might be ready to recognize Israel if it hands back the Golan Heights, captured from Syria in 1967, it reserves the right to support Palestinian and Lebanese militants as long as Israel occupies Palestinian and Lebanese territory. Real peace, say the Syrians, will have to wait for a comprehensive "grand bargain" that will settle all of Israel's conflicts with its neighbors....Luckily for Syria, perhaps, Israel is dragging its feet even more on the peace front. ..... the Netanyahu government has dodged Syrian calls for direct talks, calling instead for indirect talks whose goal would be to agree a cessation of hostilities rather than a return of the Golan Heights. That's a nonstarter for Damascus;....Merely talking about peace will only last so long, however, until talk turns again to war. And that's exactly what's happened over the past few days as Israeli and Syrian ministers have traded threats, with hard-line Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman on Thursday threatening to topple the Assad regime. "When there is another war, you will not just lose it, but you and your family will lose power," said Lieberman. So as the U.S. moves to restore relations with Damascus, its first order of business may be crisis management: to calm rising Israeli-Syrian tensions and get both sides talking again.
Russia: "IF in the future, Hypothetically, IF new sanctions are imposed, we are sure that sanctions should be limited to nonproliferation ONLY..."
"... Political directors of the six nations negotiating with Iran held a conference call Friday to discuss their next steps, but diplomats reported that the group is divided over whether and how to seek new sanctions."If in the future, hypothetically, if new sanctions are imposed, we are sure that sanctions should be limited to nonproliferation only and not be expanded to cultural, humanitarian, economic parts of Iranian activity," Russian Deputy Prime Minister Sergei Ivanov said at the Munich conference..."
Abbas does what he is 'expected' to do ...
"Following heavy international pressure, Mahmoud Abbas agreed to the U.S. proposal to hold talks with Israel .......Abbas is inclined to respond positively to the American proposal, as a refusal would shed negative light on the Palestinian position.
Senior Israeli officials noted that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu believes the talks will begin in late February and will result in the resumption of direct negotiations between Israel and the Palestinian Authority....
Abbas returned last week from a trip to Europe, where he met with German Chancellor Angela Merkel and British Prime Minister Gordon Brown. The two European leaders, who had coordinated their stance with Netanyahu and President Shimon Peres, relayed a clear message to Abbas: that they expected him to resume negotiations with Israel as soon as possible. ....
The prime minister stressed to the U.S. administration that the indirect talks be limited in terms of length of time, not exceeding two to three weeks.
"I want to reach direct talks with the Palestinians," Netanyahu said during his meeting with Moratinos last week. "I have no problem with proximity talks or indirect negotiations. I look at this as a ladder that will enable the Palestinians to climb down from the tree, and as a corridor that will lead to high-level talks."
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Saudi-Israeli relations 'outed' at last ....
"... Ayalon began his talk saying it appeared "a representative of a country with a lot of oil" had pressed the organizers to separate the panel because he "did not want to sit with us," ...... U.S. Senator Lieberman joined Ayalon's criticism, saying "I am disappointed with the Saudis," adding that he had thought that he was participating in a six-person panel, only to discover that the panels had been split because the Saudis refuse to sit with the Israelis. In the subsequent question and answer session, prince al-Faisal stood up in the audience and said it was not he who had objected and the splitting of the panel was probably due to Ayalon's "boorish behavior" with Turkey's envoy to Israel.... Ayalon responded by saying that the Saudi prince had called into question his integrity. He added: "If indeed it was not him who objected to my being here with him, I would welcome him to shake my outstretched hand." The prince refused to get on the stage, but Ayalon did not lose his stride, announcing that he would be willing to get off the stage. He then walked toward the prince and shook his hand. "Israel is committed to peace," he told the prince. The handshake was a rare public occurrence between an Israeli and a Saudi official. Prince al-Faisal holds no official post in Saudi Arabia currently, but he is considered to have a very high status among Saudi royalty. " | ||
The lessons of Iraq have been ignored. The target is now Iran
"........ Obama's "outstretched hand", always combined with the threat of sanctions or worse, appears to have been all but withdrawn.
The US vice-president, Joe Biden, underlined that by insisting Iran's leaders were "sowing the seeds of their own destruction". And in Israel, which has vowed to take whatever action is necessary to prevent Iran acquiring nuclear weapons, threats of war against its allies, Lebanon's Hezbollah and the Palestinian Hamas, are growing. "We must recruit the whole world to fight Ahmadinejad," Israeli president Shimon Peres declared on Tuesday.
The echoes of the run-up to the invasion of Iraq are unmistakable. Just as in 2002-3, we are told that a dictatorial Middle Eastern state is secretly developing weapons of mass destruction, defying UN resolutions, obstructing inspections, threatening its neighbours and supporting terrorism.
As in the case of Iraq, no evidence has been produced to back up the WMD claims, though bogus leaks about secret programmes are regularly reproduced in the mainstream press. Most recently, a former CIA official reported that US intelligence believed documents, published in the Times, purporting to show Iran planning to experiment on a "neutron initiator" for an atomic weapon, had been forged. Shades of Iraq's non-existent attempts to buy uranium in Niger.
In case anyone missed the parallels, Tony Blair hammered them home at the Iraq inquiry last Friday. Far from showing remorse about the bloodshed he helped unleash on the Iraqi people, the former prime minister was allowed to turn what was supposed to be a grilling into a platform for war against Iran.
In a timely demonstration that neoconservatism is alive and well and living in London, Blair attempted to use the fact that Iraq had no WMD as part of a case for taking the same approach against Iran. Perceived intention and potential capability were enough to justify war, it turned out. Mentioning Iran 58 times, he explained that the need to "deal" with Iran raised "very similar issues to the ones we are discussing".
You might think that the views of a man that 37% of British people now believe should be put on trial for war crimes would be treated with contempt. But Blair remains the Middle East envoy of the Quartet – the US, UN, EU and Russia – even as he pockets £1m a year from a UAE investment fund currently negotiating a slice of the profits from the exploitation of Iraqi oil reserves.......
For the US government, as during the Bush administration, the real problem is Iran's independent power in the most sensitive region in the world – heightened by the Iraq war. The signals coming out of Washington are mixed. The head of US National Intelligence implied on Tuesday there was nothing the US could do to stop Iran from developing nuclear weapons if it chose to do so. Perhaps the military build-up in the Gulf is just sabre rattling. The preference is clearly for regime change rather than war.
But Israel is most unlikely to roll over if that option fails, and the risks of the US and its allies, including Britain, being drawn into the fallout from any attack would be high. As was discovered in the case of Iraq, the views of outriders like Blair and Pipes can quickly become mainstream. If we are to avoid a replay of that catastrophe, pressure to prevent war with Iran will have to start now."
Friday, February 5, 2010
"What if Iran's hardline leadership emerges strengthened and emboldened?"
"What if Iran's hardline leadership emerges from the current confrontations at home strengthened and emboldened? If so, the nuclear issue will be back with a vengeance. And three recent war games focused on the Iranian nuclear weapons issue suggest that the prospects for halting the regime's progress toward nuclear weapons are not good....All three games have the ring of truth: they are plausible, credible, and consistent, and they reinforce other analyses suggesting that diplomacy and sanctions will not work. This leads to certain conclusions.First, the United States must "play" differently in the coming months than the participants who represented it in these simulations. Current U.S. policy seemed to fail in each game, leaving the situation worse in several dimensions: Iran was undeterred (even strengthened), relations with Israel were in crisis, and international support was lacking. Accordingly, the United States and others must conceive and develop new, more robust initiatives (e.g., strong support for regime change).Second, the United States must plan for military action, either by itself, with others, or in the wake of unilateral Israeli strikes. Both the military and the public should be prepared for the consequences of these scenarios. These preparations must be carried out with the full understanding that the military option is practicable -- and, at the end of the day, may well be the required course of action.Third, the results of these games are likely disturbing for Israel, indicating that its leaders should prepare both diplomatically and militarily to go it alone. A decision to strike could be the most fateful since the state's founding. Israel needs to ready its military not just for a raid or operation, but also for an extended war on multiple fronts and deep within the homeland. Likewise, the civilian population should prepare itself for the disruption and casualties of such a conflict. Israel already appears to be moving in this direction, and that course seems wise given the outcome of the war games. Time is running out."
"Obama has already lost three special elections... Me, I have won two legislative elections & the EU election. What can one say I've lost?"
"French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who sought during the 2008 presidential campaign to associate himself with Barack Obama, has become sharply critical of the American president, often comparing Obama unfavorably to himself, according to an article published this week in the authoritative French daily Le Monde.The article quotes Sarkozy twice recently criticizing Obama in public, and says he's twice gone on the record criticizing Obama in recent weeks. Asked last Monday in a television interview of his sweeping attempt to reform several sectors of French government simultaneously, Sarkozy pointed to Obama's made health care reform his sole focus. "I didn't see that that made things simpler," he said.
In an earlier conversation with reporters, Sarkozy compared his electoral record to Obama, says the piece, whose byline is of the Parisian correspondent for a Swiss newspaper, Le Temps, owned by Le Monde. "Obama has been in power for a year, and he has already lost three special elections. Me, I have won two legislative elections and the EU election. What can one say I've lost?" Sarkozy is quoted as asking.
The article quotes a "source well familiar with French diplomacy" suggesting the criticism has become a reflex for Sarkozy, and attributes the "unhealthy" attitude to Sarkozy's personal qualities, a matter of much fascination in France. Sarkozy, the piece speculates, got off to a bad start with Obama during last June's visit to Paris, where the French president was displeased by both the "unflattering comparison between the physique" of the two men (Obama is much taller) and by the "adulation of the Bobo left" -- not Sarkozy's base -- for the American.
The piece also quotes a Sarkozy advisor, Alain Minc, expressing what it claims is Sarkozy's true view of Obama in Le Parisien: "He's a charmer, a conciliator, but I am not sure that he's a strong leader in a crisis writing."
The new piece picks up on a theme in the French press that began when, during the June trip, the Obamas did not find time to dine with Sarkozy and his wife in Paris, and took flight last fall. One expressed worry: That Obama considers Sarkozy merely one foreign leader among many."
"Will Netanyahu and Lieberman's political escalation translate to military escalation?"
"... As-Safir and Al Akhbar, two Lebanese newspapers considered sympathetic to Hezbollah, ran editorials Friday questioning Israel's motives and military preparedness.Samir Karam, writing in As-Safir (in Arabic), criticized Israeli military strategy for failing to evolve with the conflict, citing a report by the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs on Israel's qualitative military edge."[The study's authors] want to make a fuss about ending the doctrine of qualitative military edge, while emphasizing that Israel still has this qualitative edge, despite developments that would destroy [this advantage]," Karam wrote. "What can Israel do to restore this qualitative edge, which [was damaged by] the resistance, not armies?"In Al Akhbar (in Arabic), Saadallah Mazraani accused Israeli politicians of using political and military provocation to shift focus from reaching a two-state solution."Will Netanyahu and Lieberman's political escalation translate to military escalation?" he asked, and if so, will it be in Gaza, Lebanon, Iran or Syria?"But there is a risk: despite the natural tendency of Israeli leaders toward war and aggression, despite the presence of an extremist group in a position of unprecedented power in Israel, despite the fact that this group is supported by influential powers in the American administration. ... Despite all this, despite the lure of official Arab complicity and Palestinian division ... the facts on the ground do not make the Israeli adventure easy. ... The war will not be limited, and the resistance will be wider and more effective."